I don't get the gripes on the Rogue HS. She's been drawn / sculpted / animated so many times that she doesn't have a distinct face anymore, she's basically identified by the hair.
Do agree that Harding sculpts aren't quite the second coming - he nails it sometimes, then flubs on others.
Feel we are in an era whehich will be remembered more for overdone lip paint apps than sculpts, however.
What amuses me about this head sculpt is I've seen a Hoary Host of comparisons across media, and it's just a varied, inconsistent assortment of women with every little features in common. Less so this thread, more Facebook and YouTube and Reddit.
Anyway, for myself, this look is a Jim Lee thing, but... His female faces then were very minimal, and I can't think of any action figures outside of the Mafex Hush line that really capture him. Well, maybe the DCD Hush line before.
Even the assortment of commissions and official art (that new series, as example) still don't hit as that Rogue for me, because as you explain, artists so rarely keep her actual features consistent. Which is also interesting to me because I find Storm, Jean, Selina Kyle (circa Cooke on) tend to have an agreed upon jawline and headshape, etc. I dunno, that's just something I mind with my own illustration.
Anyway!
So excited to descend into the abbatoire for this and the Episode 3 set and Slither. Love you, Hasbro!