joshsquash729
Born on the cob
Little Shop is one of my favorite musicals. I even played Mr. Mushnik in high school. I've always been something of a crotchety old man, I suppose. As much as I like the ambiguously happy ending to the movie, it's the Director's Cut for me all the way. I went to a screening of it pre-pandemic with Frank Oz and listened to him talk about it, and while I've forgotten most of what he said, he did say it's his preferred ending, so that's really all I need.
I do agree that Seymour is softened a bit in the movie. Not like he's hard edge or anything in he show- he's still a loser- but he does some pretty bad things; certainly more our "protagonist" than our "hero". Both a victim of circumstance and later his own choices. The only character I'd say is truly good is Audrey. It's running off-Broadway now, and I've seen it with a couple different casts. It's always interesting to see who the next Seymour and Audrey are- the former especially. There's been plenty of the "conventionally attractive younger man" playing him who, while they definitely do a good job with the material, kinda lend a different vibe to Seymour. Not that Rick Moranis is ugly or anything, but he's certainly not your traditional leading man. So Seymour can certainly come off a little incel-y at times, depending on who's playing him- how old or young they are, their mannerisms, etc. Not a knock at all, just an interesting take on the character.
Obviously I get why folks like happy endings, back then and today more than ever, but I always appreciate the message behind a thing. Little Shop is, if anything, a cautionary tale while also being a tribute to old sci-fi, which often ended on downer notes because they mirrored real world things. Were it ever to be re-made, I'd hope they'd stick with the true ending, and maybe even show the characters as parts of the plant like they do in the stage show (I know it's just a way to have the actors on stage, but was always a morbid little detail I appreciated).
I do agree that Seymour is softened a bit in the movie. Not like he's hard edge or anything in he show- he's still a loser- but he does some pretty bad things; certainly more our "protagonist" than our "hero". Both a victim of circumstance and later his own choices. The only character I'd say is truly good is Audrey. It's running off-Broadway now, and I've seen it with a couple different casts. It's always interesting to see who the next Seymour and Audrey are- the former especially. There's been plenty of the "conventionally attractive younger man" playing him who, while they definitely do a good job with the material, kinda lend a different vibe to Seymour. Not that Rick Moranis is ugly or anything, but he's certainly not your traditional leading man. So Seymour can certainly come off a little incel-y at times, depending on who's playing him- how old or young they are, their mannerisms, etc. Not a knock at all, just an interesting take on the character.
Obviously I get why folks like happy endings, back then and today more than ever, but I always appreciate the message behind a thing. Little Shop is, if anything, a cautionary tale while also being a tribute to old sci-fi, which often ended on downer notes because they mirrored real world things. Were it ever to be re-made, I'd hope they'd stick with the true ending, and maybe even show the characters as parts of the plant like they do in the stage show (I know it's just a way to have the actors on stage, but was always a morbid little detail I appreciated).