Fwoosh Top 10 Vote Results

[Beamish]

Here are the results of the Fwoosh Top 10 Poll, pulled from Fwoosh so we have the list in case Fwoosh goes down:


Here's the Top 10 Standard Figures! (Well, 11 due to a tie)


#1 Skurge the Executioner (2 votes were BAF/Deluxe) - 23 Votes
#2-3 (tie) Attuma - 16 Votes
#2-3 (tie) Rachel Summers (all votes were variations of Excalibur, Phoenix and Hound) - 16 Votes
#4 Marrina - 15 Votes
#5 Psylocke (9 votes were Armored/Outback, 2 votes Disassembled, 1 vote 80s, 1 vote "pink gown" which is the early costume with the puffy-ish sleeves) - 13 Votes
#6 Jack of Hearts - 12 Votes
#7 Mantis (4 votes specifically said human/flesh tone skin) - 11 Votes
#8-9 (tie) Feral (4 votes were X-Force) - 9 Votes
#8-9 (tie) Mandarin (2 votes were for the 1960s green/purple suit with the pointy mask, 1 vote bare chest costume, 1 vote green robes (Face Off), 1 vote flesh tone green armor from the 3 3/4 figure) - 9 Votes
#10-11 (tie) Magik (4 votes were classic New Mutants with metal arm, 1 vote larger body, 1 vote post-Limbo gold, 1 vote Darkchylde) - 8 Votes
#10-11 (tie) Magma (Several votes and pictures indicated the powered up look) - 8 Votes


7 Votes
Anaconda (2 votes BAF)
Deathbird
Gargoyle
Hepzibah (1 vote skunky fresh)
Kitty Pryde (3 votes Astonishing, 2 votes Sprite/1st appearance, 1 vote Excalibur II, 1 vote Shadowkat assassin)
Swordsman
Valkyrie (1 vote 70s Defenders, 1 vote Brunhilda)

6 Votes
Colossus (3 votes Outback of which one vote was BAF/Deluxe, 2 votes Astonishing, 1 vote Jim Lee/90s Gold Team suit)
Exodus
Firebird (1 vote cape included)
Mephisto (1 vote Deluxe with throne)
Synch (2 votes Generation X)
Wizard

5 Votes
Air-Walker (1 vote BAF/Deluxe)
Cannonball (3 votes 90s X-Men/Onslaught, 1 vote classic New Mutants, 1 vote Zero Tolerance)
Colleen Wing
Falcon (70s red & white suit)
Gorgon
Jubilee (4 votes Generation X, 1 vote Vampire)
Namorita (all votes variations of classic early NW, green costume, human skin tone)
Skin (Generation X)
Starfox
Storm (2 votes AoA, 1 vote Avengers/From the Ashes, 1 vote Disassembled, 1 vote Outback suit with lightning insignia and long hair

4 Votes
Beast (2 votes Perez sculpt, 1 vote Astonishing, 1 vote X-Terminators)
Cardiac
Cypher (2 votes classic New Mutants, 2 votes Krakoa-era suit)
Graviton
Iron Man (3 votes Improvised Armor/Ohta design/Model 74, 1 vote modern Tony Stark, no armor)
Madcap
Moonstone (Masters of Evil)
Swarm
Penance (Generation X)
Pixie
Sidewinder
Thor (2 votes Heroic Age/Coipel, 1 vote silver age, 1 vote Simonson armored)
Triton
Werewolf By Night (1 vote both wolf forms)
Wiccan
Wonder Man (3 votes classic/90s WCA, 1 vote first appearance)
Yellowjacket

3 Votes
America Chavez (comic)
Balder
Baron Blood
Blade (2 votes 70s first appearance, 1 vote Nightstalkers)
Blastaar
Bucky (classic Invaders/golden age)
Captain Britain (first appearance/original costume)
Carrion
Crimson Dynamo
Cyclops (1 vote Byrne, 1 vote graduation suit, 1 vote New Mutants/Morrison)
Death Adder
Dr. Druid
Echo (MCU)
Edwin Jarvis
Ghost Rider (Robbie Reyes)
Hogun
Nebula (1 vote Buscema)
Overdrive
Plantman (2 votes cape & mask)
Red Wolf (2 votes bronze age, 1 vote with Lobo)
Silhouette (1 vote first New Warriors look)
Stingray
Talisman (Elizabeth Twoyoungmen)
Trapster
Two-Gun Kid (Matt Hawk silver age)
Vermin
Wolverine (Team X)

2 Votes
Adam Warlock (1 vote bronze age Starlin)
Baron Mordo
Battlestar
Boomerang (classic)
Bug
Calypso (classic)
Chitauri (MCU)
Daredevil (1 vote classic, 1 vote Secret Wars)
Diablo
Diamondback
Fandral
Gamora (classic, 1 vote Starlin)
Gladiator (Potter)
Greycrow/Scalphunter (classic Marauders)
Hellion
Human Torch (Jim Hammond – golden age)
Jean Grey (1 vote X-Factor green, 1 vote X-Men Red)
Lilith Drake
Man-Wolf (Stargod)
Mary Jane Watson (first appearance/John Romita)
Mastermind
Meteorite
Mimic
Mole Man
Nightcrawler (90s AoA)
Owl
Pete Wisdom (comic, 1 vote extra head with eye patch – X-Force)
Phantom Rider
Phyla-Vell
Pip the Troll (comic)
Raza Longknife
Revanche (90s)
Rogue (1 vote Savage Land, 1 vote Uncanny Avengers)
Ronin (New Avengers)
Sabretooth (1 vote Captive – Phalanx Covenant, 1 vote Team X)
Sage (1 vote X-Treme X-Men, 1 vote red and black suit
Senyaka (1 vote Acolyte)
Sersi (classic green)
Sunspot (1 vote fully powered up)
Surge
Techno (1 vote first Thunderbolts look)
Typhoid Mary (classic)
Volcana (Secret Wars)
White Tiger (Hector Ayala)
Wasp (1 vote Under Siege, 1 vote black and yellow modern)
Wolfsbane (1 vote Excalibur)

1 Vote
Abomination (classic on bigger body)
Absorbing Man (classic)
Abyss (AoA)
Ahab
Albert & Elsie Dee
Amelia Voght (Acolyte)
Americop
Angelica Jones (Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends)
Anole
Arabian Knight (Sinbad look)
Ares (Dark Avengers)
Aunt May
Aunt May (MCU)
Baron Von Strucker (Earth’s Mightiest Heroes)
Basilisk (Basil Elks 80s handbook)
Bishop (AoA)
Black Mamba
Blink (X-Men Days of Futures Past movie)
Bobby Drake (Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends)
Bolt (NW volume 2)
Bullseye (Dark Avengers)
Captain America (MCU First Avenger)
Captain Mar-Vell (Starlin)
Captain Ultra
Cecilia Reyes
Chamber (Generation X uniform with jacket)
Crippler
Cyclops (Fox, Apocalypse end scene)
Daken
Dani Moonstar (with Valkyrie accessories)
Darcy Lewis (MCU)
Daredevil (MCU – She-Hulk)
Deadly Nightshade (classic)
Defensor
Demolition Man
Diamond Lil
Doc Samson
Domino (ToyBiz Greg Capullo blue and purple costume)
Dr. Doom (classic)
Dr. Octopus (white Armani suit with bendy tentacles)
Dr. Strange (Modern – Savage Avengers)
Dracula (70s Gene Colan style)
Drax the Destroyer (Hercules retro buck)
Dust
Echo (New Avengers)
El Aguila
Elven
Emma Frost (Generation X)
Fat Cobra
Frankenstein’s Monster (classic)
Frenzy (post Age of X)
General Ross (Modern)
Genis-Vell (90s legacy)
Ghoul (Jonathan Martin)
Goblin Queen (Inferno)
Goliath (Hank Pym)
Grandmaster
Green Goblin (silver age with bat-wing Goblin Glider)
Guang Bo (MCU)
GW Bridge
Harry Osborn (classic 616)
Harvest (Phalanx Covenant)
Black Mamba, Princess Python)
Havok (AoA)
Hawkeye (Hawkguy) with Pizza Dog
Heimdall
Hercules (70s classic skirt)
High Evolutionary (MCU)
Hydra Soldier (Earth’s Mightiest Heroes)
Iceman (Portacio/Lee)
Iceman (Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends)
Ikari
Invisible Woman (1995 opera gloves suit)
Jimmy Woo
Jolt (first Thunderbolts look)
Julia Carpenter (Sony, Madame Web)
Kaecilius
Karma
Karnak (ANAD)
Karolina Dean
Killraven
Kraven (PS5)
Kurse (MCU)
Kylun
Layla Miller
Leader (90s Hulk cartoon)
Legion (FX Legion tv show)
Living Lightning
Living Mummy (classic)
Loki
Lord Pumpkin
Luna Snow
Mandrill
Mantra I (Eden Blake/Lucanz)
Marvel Boy (first NW look, swappable heads & removable cape)
Master of the World
Maverick (Team X)
Medusa
Moira X
Mondo
Mr. Knight
Ms. Marvel (X-uniform)
Multiple Man (X-Factor)
Nebula (MCU, Endgame)
Night Thrasher
Nightcrawler (Fox, Apocalypse end scene)
Nightmare
Nightwatch (NOT Deathwatch)
Nomad (Jack Monroe)
Peter Parker (Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends)
Polaris (Giant-Size X-Men)
Prime
Prototype (Jimmy Ruiz)
Punisher (trench coat from Epic Heroes wave)
Puppet Master
Quicksilver (AoA)
Rancor
Reaper (MLF)
Red Guardian II (Tania Belinskaya)
Reese (Reavers)
Rick Jones – A-Bomb
Rintrah
Robbie Robertson
Rocket Raccoon (MCU, Endgame)
Rocket Racer
Rogue (Animated series neon green)
Ruby Thursday
Satanna (classic/Vampire Tales)
Scarlet Witch (ANAD)
Scorpion (PS4)
Shang-Chi (with gi top)
Shocker (PS4)
Shotgun (Punisher War Zone costume)
Shroud
Sif
Simon Garth, Zombie (classic)
Slapstick
Spider-Man (Ultimate 6160)
Spider-Slayer
Spot
Spyke (X-Men Evolution)
Stardust
Storm (Fox, Apocalypse end scene)
Tempo (classic, with alternate modern head)
Tempus
Texas Twister
The Maker
Thing (Fantastic Four tank tops, pants and boots)
Troll (Gunna Sijurvald)
Turbo (first NW look)
Uncle Ben Parker
Vanguard
Vector
Vengeance
Viv Vision
War Machine (MCU, Infinity War)
Wasp (Earth’s Mightiest Heroes)
Whiplash (MCU)
Whizzer (golden age/70s)
Wild Thing
X-23 (Deadpool & Wolverine)
Ying Nan (MCU)
Yuki
Zelma Stanton
Zzzax (90s Hulk cartoon)



Top BAF/Deluxe Figures! (Well, 6 due to a tie)

14 Votes
Armor (1 vote standard size, 1 vote Astonishing)

7 Votes (TIE)
M'Baku (2 votes standard size)
Stegron (2 votes standard size, 1 vote Lizard size)

4 Votes (TIE)
Annihilus (2 votes standard size)
Box (1 vote specifically Roger Bochs, 1 vote classic red or blue)
Volstagg (1 vote standard size)

3 Votes
Titanium Man (1 vote for Gremlin armor)

2 Votes
Aragorn (1 vote included Brightwind, also removable wings)
Bushmaster
Gatecrasher
Holocaust (AoA)
Hulk (Merged Hulk, 1 vote Pantheon-era jumpsuit)
Hulk (Smart Hulk, 1 vote standard size)
Hulkling (1 vote standard size)
Iceman (with ice accessories)
Shuma Gorath

1 Vote
Banshee (Phantom Rider’s horse)
Bi-Beast (2008 Hulk video game)
Champion of the Universe
Destroyer (MCU)
In-Betweener
Mondo (Generation X)
NM-E
Onslaught (AoA)
Phoenix firebird in blue
Rhino (Ultimate)
Rockslide
Sasquatch
Varnae, Lord of the Vampires



TOP HASLAB/MADE-TO-ORDER

7 Votes
Fin Fang Foom

4 Votes
Atlas (2 votes 90s/Thunderbolts), 1 vote was BAF/Deluxe)
Cameron Hodge
Mangog (1 vote BAF/Deluxe)

3 Votes
Goliath (Eric Josten)

2 Votes
Awesome Android
Black Goliath (1 vote BAF/Deluxe size with the yellow collar, chest/abdomen open costume)
Danger Room (1 vote 90s modular, 1 vote diorama including X-Jet cockpit/cabin, War Room)
Devil Dinosaur
FantastiCar/Fantasticar II
Goliath (Clint Barton, 1 vote specifically 15 to 18 inches)
Griffin (1 vote standard size)
Living Monolith
Quinjet (MCU)
Surtur (1 vote Simonson)

1 Vote
Hulk (starship)
Krakoa (as a tree)
Phalanx (modular army builder set)
Red Ronin
Satannish
Super-Adaptoid
Supreme Intelligence
Terminus
Watcher (bronze age)
X-Jet
Yellowjacket

 

[TheSameIdiot]

Thanks for all you do, Beamish.

As an FYI, I spoke to Beamish about running the next top 10. He's on board.

When the time comes, we'll have threads for top 10 voting and discussion/results.

 

[hmmberto]

Thanks for reposting Beamish, and for the update TSI! Beamish, if you ever want any support in running the Top 10 please let me know. I'd be happy to pitch in and set up a system to make the collection and tallying of votes a little easier - but only if you are interested.

 

[docsilence]

Thanks for reposting! Always fun to see what gets made after the vote. Glad we won't lose that historical information.

 

[NORM]

Copying my votes from Fwoosh just for my own reference:

Skurge the Executioner
Gladiator (Melvin Potter)
Colleen Wing
Hepzibah (Starjammers)
Skin (Generation X)
Wonder Man (WCA)
Yellowjacket
Ares (Dark Avengers)
Ronin (New Avengers)
Echo (New Avengers)

BAF M'Baku

HasLab Yellowjacket

 

[TheSameIdiot]

Good thought. My 2024 top 10:

Psylocke (Armored)
Thor (Heroic Age/Coipel)
Magik
Blade (First appearance)
Rogue (Uncanny Avengers)
Moira X
Loki
Kitty Pryde (Astonishing)
Phyla-Vell
Mephisto

BAF: Armor

HasLab: Mangog

 

[Justice]

Grabbed mine too.


1. Dr. Druid

2. Mantis (Classic, human skin tone)

3. Marinna

4. Magma (powered up look)

5. Starfox

6. Firebird

7. Psylocke (Armored Outback costume)

8. Rachel Summers (Excalibur)

9. Namorita (Green Costume, human skin tone)

10. Silhouette



BAF: Gatecrasher

MTO/Haslab: Goliath (Clint Barton)

 

[docsilence]

This was mine:

• Colleen Wing [Comic]
• Karnak [ANAD]
• Rachel Summers [Excalibur]
• America Chavez [Comic]
• Hawkeye [Hawkguy] - with Pizza Dog please
• Sersi [Comic - Green Costume - a better fit alongside that magnificent Ikaris this year]
• Diamondback [Comics]
• Black Mamba
• Red Wolf (AND LOBO - just reuse Timber's buck from Classified!)
• Peter Wisdom [Comics - extra head with his eyepatch from that X-Force run where he was gaslighting Nick Fury by wearing an eyepatch just to be a jerk]

BAF Bushmaster

Haslab: Fin Fang Foom

Bonus with above - any other Serpent Society; an update to that one decent but now outdated Kate Bishop to go with Hawkguy (please a three pack of those goofballs), and Peter Wisdom is my favorite of three spy-type characters in the running for the tenth spot beating out Abigail Brand and Victoria Hand. I just like Pete best.

 

[puckace]

Good idea to have one's personal Top Ten over here as well.

Tough to pare the list down to 10 and a couple oversize options.

All classic versions in no particular order.

1. Mantis flesh toned yellow/green outfit

2. Swordsman

3. Skurge/Executioner

4. Wizard

5. Attuma

6. Mandarin flesh toned green armor look from the 3 3/4" Iron Man line

7. Stegron classic Lizard size preferred

8. Sidewinder

9. Anaconda

10. Air-Walker last essential herald to go with Galactus

M'Baku/Man Ape BAF

Surtur (Simonson) HasLab

Legends really needs to fill out some of the more iconic Marvel villains.

 

[BasilElks]

Owl
Cardiac
Colleen Wing
Plantman (70s cape and mask)
Shroud
Madcap
Basilisk (Basil Elks) {80s handbook look}
Calypso
Carrion (80s handbook look)
Shotgun (90s Handbook look)

BAF Stegron
Haslab Goliath (Erik Josten)

 

[Beamish]

My Top 10 List from the Fwoosh 2025 vote,
All classic versions, with one possible exception:
1) Jack of Hearts
2) Skurge the Executioner
3) Mantis - human skin tone preferred, but green would be ok.
4) Gargoyle
5) Attuma
6) Swarm
7) Firebird - classic preferred with removable cape, but her modern costume looks great, too.
8) Red Wolf
9) Stingray
10) Two-Gun Kid
BAF/Deluxe - M'Baku
HasLab/Oversize - Awesome Android

Here's the kicker: Deathbird is my #1 want, but since she was on the rumor/leak list, I didn't include her.
My personal Top 10 would have Deathbird at #1, bumping Two-Gun Kid off the list to #11.

 

[Ultra Seven]

1) Kitty Pryde (Training Uniform)
2) Psylocke (Mutant Massacre)
3) Phoenix (Rachel Grey)
4) Iron Fist (Classic)
5) Namorita (Classic)
6) Valkyrie (Classic)
7) Beast (George Perez)
8) Hepzibah
9) Raza
10) Magma

... really the full classic New Mutants line-up is higher than most of these, but I wanted my list to cover as wide a group of characters as possible, and they'd eat more than half of the slots.

 

[Reno]

Only never before made characters for me, we get enough repeats/updates/alternate costumes as is in my opinion...

1) Rockslide
2) Pixie
3) Anole
4) Armor
5) Robbie Robertson
6) Edwin Jarvis
7) Magma
8) Cypher
9) Sage
10) Rick Jones

 

[PanchaMaestro]

Here was mine. What was I thinking?

1Swarm
2 Skurge
3 Attuma
4. Blastaar
5. Nebula (classic)
6. Gamora (classic)
7. Adam Warlock (classic)
8. Annhilus
9-10 & BAF Warriors 3

Made to order: Mangog

Characters I'm assuming the rumors of their impending production I took to be true so didn't include. Gorgon & Triton.

Characters it pained me to not include: Classic Falcon, Mantis, Princess Python, Diablo, Wizard, all the 80s Masters of Evil characters we are missing, Baron Mordo, Mephisto, Nightmare, Pip the troll, Baron Blood