I identify as a xennial as well (1978 baby here). I definitely got raised with the expectations levied on GenX (do better than your parents, pull yourself up by your bootstraps, ludicrous ideas about dinner job interviews that you’d blow if you held your fork the wrong way), and arrived in the post-college “adult” world just 16 months or so before 9/11. I *definitely* identify more with millennial adult experiences (no way you’re gonna do better than your parents, “bootstraps” is a classist myth, job interviews?, good luck getting through the algorithmic sorting pile), and I woke up pretty fast from the foolish mythology I was pumped full of as a 90s, Silicon Valley-raised teen re: capitalism, equality (or lack thereof), etc.
And THEE biggest lesson, as TSI pointed out, is the issue of the paradox of tolerance. I used to abide by the “Darth Vader approach”, you know “there’s good in you, I can feel it, let go of your hate!” And like, OK, on a one-to-one level this CAN work, but you also have a huge chance of being influenced by the other person’s viewpoint, which is usually not such a bad thing but in the case of MAGA beliefs it would be like someone trying to help a guy get off heroin and then thinking “hmmm maybe I should give that stuff a try, just once, just to see”. And guess what? One shot of heroin can make you an addict *instantly”.
“Aww, but MAGA isn’t as dangerous and poisonous as heroin, and certainly not as addictive.”
Unfortunately the answers are “yes”, “definitely yes” and “hell yes it is”.
And, like heroin, there is no equal and opposing thing to do instead and/or to blame when the heroin makes you do and feel and say awful things.
Like I work professionally with folks stuck in cult-think, and MAGA folks still make me nervous in clinical environments. It’s not just that it’s hard to “convert” them, THEY are actively trying to “convert” ME. And yet, individual to individual, in a PROFESSIONAL setting, when the subject WANTS help, it can be worth it.
MAGA as an aggregate group?
That is a WHOLE other discussion.
Tolerance is best thought of as a social contract. MAGA, as an aggregate group, have absolutely shredded the contract by any reasonable metric. You wouldn’t “tolerate” a guy who pushes his way into your house, insults your spouse and children, steals your beer and takes a shit on your coffee table. You’d kick him the fuck out of your house, and you wouldn’t have a “nuanced discussion” about why.
Now imagine that, on a countrywide scale.
Except you don’t have to imagine, because this is where and how we are living.
After Gavin Newsom hosted Charlie Kirk on his podcast and used it as an opportunity to come out as a transphobe, a “reasonable Democrat” on my feed immediately demanded that we, as “liberals”, must be willing to have a “nuanced discussion” about trans rights and whether trans folks belong in spaces where everyone else belongs. That, my friends, is the result of “tolerance” of MAGA beliefs: demands BY A DEMOCRAT to reduce a group of humans’ rights to a “nuanced discussion”. Replace “trans” with literally any other descriptor for a group of people and it should be pretty damn clear how wrong that is, and how it plays directly into the hands of a neo-Nazi movement (we really should call things by their actual names) that has been working FOR YEARS to create “others” to designate as “enemies”. Again, this is just the plot of the Wizard and Madame Morrible from Wicked: it’s that blatantly villainous.
You start tolerating intolerance, even a little bit, even with “nuance”, and you have been co-opted by the values of the *actual* enemy. And unless you actually, enthusiastically embrace an oligarchic, christofascist ethnostate and possible technocracy (and actually understand what those things are and STILL enthusiastically want them) then MAGA is your mortal enemy.
How does all this relate to tariffs? Well, when the guy setting the tariffs is embroiled in a “me first and only me” ideology seasoned by the utter dehumanization of other folks, it’s pretty easy to understand that all of this is being done with complete disregard for the rights, dignity, and very lives of people who’s names aren’t Donald John Trump.