Quitting/putting collecting on pause

For what it's worth, it's not action figures that are upsetting me right now - it's board games. I have an art/writing studio in the basement, my little hole in the earth, and I look at the games there sometimes and have an existential crisis knowing I'll never learn to play them all, paint all the minis, and ENJOY them before I'm literally dead. Action figures? I might not have them on display but I know where they are, I can enjoy them during quiet moments. Those GAMES depress the living hell out of me. I feel like that was wasted money and lost joy.
I to have a lot of board games, many of which I've never played. My tabletop gaming group gets together less and less frequently. It used to be a weekly occurrence and now we are lucky to do it four times a year so I doubt I will ever get to them all.
 
It's funny, I actually made up a document of how my partner could sell off my collection if I drop dead first (what's valuable, what's not) and asked a friend who knows action figures to help her out if that ever happens (told him he can take whatever from the collection feels like fair compensation) and now at the end of the world, it'd be... depressingly hilarious if all of that was for nothing because we'll be pushing shopping carts around avoiding cannibals instead of sadly selling off our collections to the next generation of collectors.
 
"But I like it."

That's the phrase that keeps me from getting rid of a ton of stuff. My neighbor and her 11 year old son asked to check out my collection a few weeks ago because they see how many boxes get delivered and he was in awe and she was too. But it's too much and I know that but then I think what to get rid of and then it hits me: "But I like it."

Also, the phrase "Collect 'em all!" Ugh. I wanted to and couldn't afford to, and then I could, and now I can!

I have very few SW TVC things on display - they are mostly in boxes in boxes. But I love the dioramas and the world building - but I have zero space for that, and I'm not good at rotating. Once it's up and in the right spot, it stays for awhile. But I keep buying them in case I change my mind and I won't have to pay so much for the rare ones. Terrible. But, they are little pieces of art even though I hated trying to pose one the last time I tried. I prefer TBS - why do I need two scales of SW?!?

But I like it.
 
But I like it. Yep.

Actually, my brother and a couple of my nieces and nephews wandered into my studio a few weeks back for the first time and the WONDER on their faces. My brother, who never had much luck financially and has two kids to my none, said: I just want to come back here on my own and look at everything for hours. It was like I owned a cool museum, except I'm not precious about it and they could take things down off the shelf and mess with them. I sent him home with a Mandalorian figure in the box I'd bought for a friend but never had a chance to give to him and was like "that is not in the box because it's valuable, it's just new, you better open it and enjoy it" and he said he barely got home before taking it out of the box.

Yeah, I probably won't sell off much unless I get truly stuck. But I do have moments of wondering why I did this to myself. I'm filling the void in my soul, guys! With action figures!
 
Woof. This thread sure gives me pause.

I’ve done a couple of very small sell-offs over the years, and my folks gave away many (but not all) of my childhood toys without my permission, but other than that I just . . . have all my stuff. Very little is displayed, and also I live fairly chaotically, I usually have a “play pile” of figures on my coffee table. I’ve really never been about “value” but only about “enjoyment” when it comes to figures, and I’m definitely a “play rather than display” guy, which may be somewhat rare. Like I’ve got a drawer full of figures at my work office AND my home office, just a bunch of favorites in there that I play with all the time. I’ve always got a couple figures in my work or rehearsal bag, I always have a few to mess around with on long car rides (my wife likes to drive). I do painting and light customizing. I’ve often got art supplies and figures (sometimes in parts) strewn around.
I definitely think about how much and how many I buy, and I’m not exactly reconciled on what to do about that. The presumption has always been that we would get a house eventually (just my wife, my cat and me, currently in a 3 bedroom townhouse), so I’ve got a lot of things in boxes that are on the “to be displayed when we move” list.
Also I collect more than figures: I’m into bespoke goth clothing and leather (which I wear as well as collect), New Rock boots (same, wear these too), masks, horror memorabilia, vampire books . . . and of course my wife has related and tangential collections as well. We lead pretty unconventional lives (we’re both theatre actors, she works as a distribution manager for a cannabis cultivation firm [ironically, neither of us partake] and I’m a progressive psychotherapist) and we’re in our mid-late 40s, and I feel like we are on the brink of some kind of transition . . . I just hope it’s positive.

But yeah, I think about rising prices, and how I love to army-build Classified and Masterverse, and I get anxiety.
And I think about The Future and man, I just don’t know. I’ve never known life without the comfort of action figures. I’m super-duper neurodivergent and I basically live by my special interests because the world is fucked and I work directly in the fuckery.
I do know that I don’t enjoy selling or playing markets: it’s just not my thing and it gives me an internal executive-dysfunction “ick”. Puts me in a really weird place with all this. It’s very helpful to hear all y’all’s perspectives.
 
I get the desire to just have your stuff. I buy too much but I never buy anything without the intent to keep it forever. I do want and have a plan so my poor partner isn't stuck with boxes and shelves of action figures she could make a buck off of to, y'know. Pay for a funeral or pay off a car or if she's really lucky, run off to Greece and meet some hot young guy and enjoy the rest of her life after me or whatever.

It's funny, the past few months I've struggled to find joy in things like painting or reading or even writing when I'm not being paid for it and I got into the habit of just... sorting and reviewing my action figures. Pull out a box, check out who I don't have on a shelf somewhere, really take a look at them. It's mediative. I hate the idea of losing that now. It does feel like we're in for a bleak ride though.
 
I kinda did that, then I got addicted to listing stuff. I usually have a few dozen at any given time, but things got out of hand at one point and I had eighty.
 
It's only an addiction if it's negatively impacting your life in some way. Sounds like you were doing great; how was it out of hand?
I was mostly kidding. I guess it was an addiction inverse, though I guess the out of hand part would be selling a handful of things I regret now (out of, I dunno, hundreds), but I also refuse to rebuy anything I've sold. Probably as some kinda penance.
 
Oh god, this thread is back. I actually laughed out loud when I read the title. I thought, what better time to join a new action figure forum?

Seriously, though, this is always one of my favorite threads to read and participate in. I like reading about the circumstances around people's collections. Ordinarily, I'd feel like I was being left behind. Like I was the last fan of something fading into obscurity. I've felt that way when coworkers left a job I didn't like or friends moved out of the state I was living in. (I'm sure that comes from a deep, unresolved part of my psyche.) Here, I feel like we can offer guidance and help you regain your joy.

I've told this story at least four or five times over the years, so I'll forgive you for skipping it.

As a kid, several circumstances forced me to grow up a lot faster than I should have. I started collecting action figures when I was about 10. By that point, it already felt like I was regressing or going back for something I'd outgrown. That's a feeling I've never been able to shed. I've always felt a lot of shame around collecting. Part of it was because many of the adults in my life mocked me for collecting dolls, even at that age. I'm not sure if I started collecting to connect to the childhood I missed, or, if, to quote Marge Simpson, because I just think they're neat.

In any case, my childhood collection grew out of control. I had basically every Toy Biz Marvel Legend and subsidiary line figure. The shelves were jam-packed. The idea of not displaying everything you own was foreign to me, so I had a complete team of X-Men, but it featured five Cyclops, three Rogues, 10 Wolverines, etc., all on the same shelf. By the time I sold it off as a teenager, I hated my collection.

I picked up the hobby again in college when Hasbro got their act together and solicited the SDCC exclusive Coipel Thor. I couldn't resist. When I bought Thor, I intended to keep my new collection under 25 figures. As an X-Men fan first, that was never realistic. (My current X-Men display alone is ~20 figures.) Then Hasbro solicited the Black Series and my collection spun out of control again. 25 became 50 and then that became 200. It wasn't sustainable in a one-bedroom apartment, even one where only a handful of figures were ever on display.

As my future wife and I moved from apartment to apartment, I never had the space to display more than that. I vowed to keep my collection small enough to fit into two Detolf display cases for when we eventually owned a house. A decade later, we bought the house. I bought my Detolf cabinets (since upgraded to Coaster Curio Cabinets). I love my collection now. I rarely pose, play with, or photograph my figures, but I love looking at them. They're stationed next to me in my office and bring me a tremendous amount of joy.

I imagine I have one of the smallest collections on the board. I own about 100 figures with plans for ~20 more. I still buy a lot, but like Pancha and several others, I sell stuff all the time. It's constant pruning. If I want Mondo's Adventure Time figures but my pop culture shelf is full, I better sell something that means less to me to make room.

My secret advantage is that my parents are hoarders. For a long time, I lived in constant fear of becoming them. Sometimes when I get too much stuff in at once, I get a sick feeling in my stomach that it's too late and I've become a hoarder. Then my brain tells me it's time to purge half of my collection. I've been better at curtailing that lately, but it still lives with me in a real way.

My advice for folks who think they've amassed too much: get rid of it. Sell it on eBay, donate it, give it to a friend's kid. It'll be a huge burden off your shoulders and you'll appreciate what you have even more.

Fuck yeah, the oversharing and trauma dumping is back!
 
My advice for folks who think they've amassed too much: get rid of it. Sell it on eBay, donate it, give it to a friend's kid. It'll be a huge burden off your shoulders and you'll appreciate what you have even more.
Absolutely.

The last couple of years has gotten me into a new headspace with collecting. I don't want my collection to get much bigger at this point. I want it to get more *precise*. I want to actively avoid the idea that I need all of a thing just because it would be "complete" then. No. I want a collection that is eclectic and particular, that's a roadmap of my distinct taste and nothing else.

Some of this is I need to be saving money as I get older. Some of it is just keeping space available. But most of it, the biggest chunk of it, is dealing with my aging mother and her hoarder house. She lives alone in a 4 bedroom place and there's barely a pathway through any given room wide enough for a grown man. There are a dozen chairs and sitting furniture in the place, but never more than one in any given room that isn't filled with junk. If you try to move anything, a stack next to it will fall over, usually onto you. She won't et rid of any of it, and she's got unopened food items with "sell by" dates in 2012. And she keeps buying more.

I've decided I just don't want to be that. I want a "collection" that's small and mobile enough that someone could liquidate it in a week. That they could throw it all out in an hour. I've got a few tubs of toys in an increasing state of organization, and my plan is not to really get any more from where I am now unless I sell stuff to open that space in the collection. And I think that's a nice place to be. Maybe if I buy my own house eventually (ha ha ha) I'll expand a bit more, but outside of that, this is my goldfish bowl and I don't want to outgrow it.
 
My secret advantage is that my parents are hoarders.

Hoarding like most qualitative concepts is a spectrum and not a binary concept. I got my collecting from my mom, and I wouldn't describe her as a hoarder. She's got a pretty big rural house that's quite full of the stuff she collects, but she can have guests over and it's not hard to navigate the house.

People often throw the hoarder label around carelessly as many people also throw other terms around like racist, addict, etc, but my own definition is that it's hoarding when the items you have make it functionally difficult for anyone to navigate the space in your house. In the most extreme forms the hoarder also has almost no emotional connection to the things they're hoarding and don't even know the entirety of what they have.

For all of us it's pretty key to define where collecting crosses over into hoarding. What makes you call your parents hoarders?
 
Back
Top